The Ministry of Health published this evening (Wednesday) for public comment the recommendations of the team for examining the in vitro fertilization system in the State of Israel, this after the failures that occurred in the two IVF units at Assuta's medical centers.
A senior official reveals: this is how the well-oiled silver machine of fertility treatments in Israel works
The Ministry of Health on the suspicion of the insemination failure in Assuta Ramat Hay'il: "Severe, they did not report it"
The team, appointed by the firm's CEO Moshe Bar Siman Tov, carried out an examination of the structure of the array in order to locate structural, economic and other failures that may lead to these incidents. The committee mapped out problems on a number of key levels, including the market conditions that produce diversion of activity to private units and increased workloads in these units Some of the units and laboratories are not working properly.
In addition, in the absence of centralized planning for the deployment of services and the establishment of new units, most of the services were concentrated in the central region, in two central private institutions, and a significant inequality was created in the availability of services in the rest of the country.
The committee recommended running a program to compare market conditions between private and public providers, and increasing competition between the units. The program includes strengthening the public units and making them attractive, among other things by giving the possibility to choose a doctor without charging a fee, and by reworking the aspects of the service – in which the answer is available.
Another issue that came up is improving the standard of operation of the units and laboratories with an emphasis on the quality of care and safety by updating the mandatory criteria and standards for operating units and the work processes in the laboratories, and in particular improving the monitoring of the samples and adding advanced computer systems to prevent errors in identification. At the same time, the committee recommended the promotion of a program that would incentivize the units to improve their compliance with the aspects of staff training, equipment and technological arrays and construction infrastructure.
In the meantime, they recommended the operation of a rig that is close to the response provided in the units, by defining a maximum scope of activity in each of them (depending on the infrastructure – such as space and personnel), and limiting the performance of no more than 8,000 treatment cycles (egg extractions and embryo retrieval) per year in the unit These changes will be carried out alongside monitoring the gradual increase in capacity in other units in a way that does not create operational problems or long queues.
The committee also recommended the establishment of mechanisms that would define the form of work required in IVF units that would allow a work routine to be maintained, including multi-professional team discussions and control by the unit's manager, and would also allow patients to receive comprehensive care (nurses, OB, US, doctor /e, etc.) in the unit in a way that will improve the quality and safety of the treatment and increase the satisfaction of the patients. To this end, it is recommended to examine the possibility of determining that all of the unit's doctors will be employed as employees, at least part-time.
At the same time, it was also recommended to promote moves that also relate to economic regulation, including curbing the payment mechanism for the doctor within the framework of operations in which a party that funds SEL is involved (separating 'private-private'). As well as an examination of the existing pricing in the public system and the incentives that the price creates in the private and public system. In addition, the committee stated that the implementation of IVF activity within the framework of the health insurance plan should be examined, and the change of the mechanism should be considered so that the reward is given only for activity provided by a public provider.