"Both sides are bleeding and exhausted": Where is the confrontation between the High Court and the government going?

Dozens of reservists and parents of members of the Israel Defense Forces will gather today (Wednesday) at the Supreme Court, in order to submit a petition to issue orders to the government regarding its decision not to enforce conscription of ultra-Orthodox members. Attorney Moshe Gilad, a retired district court judge, discussed this this morning with Gadi Ness on his radio show North 104.5FM.

Commissioner: "The police have one compass – the law"; Ben Gvir: "Whoever is elected dictates policy"

At the beginning of his remarks, he explained that "the High Court will deal with it – there are tools for judges, but the main issue I want to address – here is an example where the reason for reasonableness can come into consideration. What is the story here actually? Things are simple – the law has expired and therefore those ultra-Orthodox who should have been mobilized are not being recruited and the government decided to wait a little longer, to postpone the matter. Is it reasonable? This is the question".

The retired judge also sought to clarify that "this illustrates that there is a need on the one hand for a strong High Court and on the other hand for governance, that the government will come and say that every decision cannot go through the High Court. After all, turning the High Court into the government is also wrong. The High Court is a tool for the interpretation of the law and the debate is about the interpretation of the law."

Referring to the fear of a constitutional crisis, he said: "I have tears in my eyes when I say this, but the fist fight between the government and the Supreme Court has become the same as it was at the beginning – without gloves, so everything hurts the other side's flesh. I am not a politician and I will not be a politician, but I That means one thing – any change should be made by agreement. If there is no agreement, there is no change. Period."

In conclusion, Attorney Gilad noted that "we need to calm down the situation and go back a moment. If we return to the metaphor of the boxing match, every three minutes there is one minute of break. Here too, you need to take a break and lower the flames. Before fixing, you have to stop destroying. A solution can be reached in the Knesset – when it comes to constitutional matters, the opposition and the coalition give everyone a free hand to vote in secret, so that we know exactly what the people really want. After all, 120 Knesset members represent the people. Now, we have crossed the line. Both sides are exhausted and bleeding, you need to stop and think."


source

Related Breaking News

Latest Headlines

Never Miss the Important Stories

Three quick briefings a day.

The key Israel news you need to know, straight to your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.