Former Minister of Justice: "In my opinion, the considerations of the High Court are political"

Prof. Daniel Friedman, former Minister of Justice, spoke today (Wednesday) with Ben Caspit and Nissim Mashal on their program on 103FM and expressed his position regarding the fear of a constitutional crisis if the High Court intervenes or rejects secrecy laws, in preparation for the discussions that will be held in September on the cancellation of the reason for reasonableness and The law of fortification .

According to him, "This is a political crisis, there is a struggle going on that is actually a power struggle for the distribution of powers between the government and the majority in the Knesset and the court. This struggle has actually been going on here for a long time, it has been going on quietly, gradually for many years and now it has erupted with much greater force. This A struggle that is fundamentally a political struggle. During Ben-Gurion's time it was clear that the Supreme Court was subject to the laws of the Knesset, the court did not argue with any law. After that, the political echelon became very weak since Yom Kippur, this weakness caused many forces to come in, the ultra-Orthodox, the settlers and this also the legal system".

He also added: "This means, for example, certain laws that in the past there was no question about them, now the court can cancel them or change them. The Supreme Court is actually also a legislative body, there are laws in the State of Israel that were enacted by a court, some of them are very good and some of them, in my opinion , less good, for example, one law that a minister cannot serve on an indictment is a law that the court established."

As for the statements of the former heads of the security branches and the current commissioner who said that 'if there is an opposition between a government order and the law, we go with the law', he wondered: "The question is what is the law? When the court enacts a law or when the Knesset enacts a law, which law is better? The question is political and it is a question of political power. In the days when the court decided about Netanyahu, his political power was very weak and he could not afford to face the question, in the meantime the political picture has changed. In my opinion, the considerations are political, they won't find out. The question is whether the verdict reveals the real considerations to you, you can't be sure of that."

Friedman returned and assessed: "There is no legal basis for this whole discussion, the only thing they will tell you is that there is some supreme value system from which the court derives its power, what is the supreme system? Israel is a democratic state. Some will say that democracy is voting for the Knesset, some will say that democracy is Values. The question of what inclusive democracy is is a political question, like the question of what the law should be?"

In conclusion, he claimed: "I said that there is a political struggle here and this is one political force saying, 'We will not leave the power only to the Knesset, let's change the situation, we want to give the court the power to decide on the basis of supreme values that it itself will determine what they are,' and the supreme values are Democracy as the court understands it. And if the court understands that it needs to have control over reasonableness, then it will do it. By the way, the court has tools to create a form of interim solutions."

Assisted in the preparation of the article: Noya Hasson 103FM


source

Related Breaking News

Latest Headlines

Never Miss the Important Stories

Three quick briefings a day.

The key Israel news you need to know, straight to your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.