It appears: the government has submitted a request from the High Court to postpone the hearing on the cancellation of the reason for reasonableness by three weeks, due to the tight time frame. The hearing is expected to take place in September, a month before the retirement of judges Esther Hayut and Anat Baron . Which is another point of friction between her and the government officials.
A legal expert explains: Does the High Court have the authority to invalidate fundamental laws?
The fear of a constitutional crisis is increasing: "There is a very high chance that the High Court will reasonably intervene"
If it is finally decided to ask the High Court to postpone the hearing for a month and the request is accepted, this will have a dramatic effect. Judges can write judgments for some time after retiring from the judiciary, but cannot sit in hearings after their retirement. If the new date of the hearing is after the retirement of President Hayut Jurisdiction On October 16, the composition of Supreme Court judges will lose Hayut and Baron, who are considered more activist.
This move could harm the majority of the judges who will side with the fact that for the first time the High Court of Justice will reject an amendment to the Basic Law. As you may recall, the Legal Adviser to the Government informed the Minister of Justice Yariv Levin that she would allow the government independent representation in the hearing due to differences in approaches. The Legal Adviser to the Government is expected to ask the High Court, for the second time in history , cancel an amendment to the Basic Law.
The first time the legal adviser to the government asked to take the drastic step was in relation to the fortification law enshrined in the government's basic law. In this procedure, the judges decided that the amendment to the Basic Law would not be repealed. Now, the legal adviser to the government is expected to ask the judges once again to cancel an amendment to the basic law.
The government is represented by lawyer Ilan Bombach, one of Israel's top lawyers who represents many high-profile cases. Bombach's expected request follows the need to prepare for the hearing, which will begin with the issuance of a conditional order that shifts the burden of persuasion to the government that requests not to repeal the law – to the petitioners seeking to repeal it and the legal advisor to the government who is expected to join them. However, despite Bombach's real need for postponing the hearing, as mentioned, the approval of the request can have far-reaching implications.
In an interview with 103FM yesterday, the lawyer Bombach said that "if they do, God forbid, basic laws are abolished, which is a real revolution because this has never happened in practice, can the court define for itself the limits of its authority. A person cannot define for himself, not even house judges The law, the matter of authority. This is something that is very problematic. Everyone talks about democracy, but one thing must be remembered – the government and the Knesset are elected every four years in a democratic manner."
Attorney Bombach summed up his words, declaring that "a court cannot determine the authority for itself. Separation of powers, I want the Supreme Court to be authorized to rule, I do not want it to be authorized to invalidate, to govern. He will not be authorized to come and set basic laws himself – that is done in the Knesset."