The Public Defender's Office today (Thursday) expressed clear opposition to the bill by Knesset member Zvika Vogel from Otzma Yehudit that would allow Ben Gabir to order administrative arrests, at the request of the commissioner and with the approval of the ombudsman, the state attorney or their deputies.
With Otzma Yehudit they attack the ombudsman: "sticking sticks in the wheels"
A committee will be established, the Shin Bet is expected to intervene: Netanyahu's instructions for fighting violence in the Arab sector
In the position paper, the Public Defender's Office states that there is no disputing the need to deal with serious phenomena of serious crime, including in Arab society. However, the difficult events in Arab society require in-depth solutions, as opposed to 'magic solutions'. According to them, "this bill – similar to other initiatives being considered these days – constitutes a dramatic change in the world order in criminal enforcement in Israel, and it even casts a deep and fundamental influence on the nature of the democratic regime."
"Administrative detention of a person presumed to be innocent – without sufficient evidentiary infrastructure, without reasonable suspicion of committing a criminal offense and relying only on intelligence information about future and explosive fear, and in fact without a time limit – constitutes a fatal violation of the right to freedom and dignity. The mechanism proposed in the bill, under which In certain circumstances, arresting a person without being at all aware of the nature of the suspicions against him and without him and his lawyer being exposed to the evidence underlying the request for arrest – even seriously harms the fairness of the procedure and the citizen's ability to properly defend himself. The proposed administrative restrictions – which affect all lifestyles – result in the violation of many other fundamental rights such as Freedom of movement, freedom of occupation and freedom of expression, and may also include innocent people in the obligation," they added.
Her lawyers added that due to the fear of "over-enforcement, selective enforcement and damage to equality before the law" they are calling for the bill to be rejected outright. The bill will grant authority similar to the authority that the Minister of Defense has and relates to the prevention of terrorism, but Ben Gvir is asking for additional and unprecedented powers that will be given to him exclusively. According to the bill, the Minister of National Security will be able to order on his own the deposit of a passport, reporting to a police station, a ban on communicating with certain parties, a ban on calling on the Internet and imposing work-related restrictions.
It should be noted that Ben Gvir himself, as a defense attorney, strongly opposed the imposition of administrative prisons in the territories of Judea and Samaria by the General of the Central Command. Now, Ben Gvir is asking for the possibility of imposing administrative arrests in the entire State of Israel when the authority to impose such an arrest warrant will be in the hands of a politician.